Thank you so much, Valerie! My real issue was that I was using one report to run stats both emails. So in the smart list, I had the selected filter as you showed in the screen shot, but had a filter for each email that was a/b tested as well.
Removing the filters and running the report for each email separately gave me exactly what I was looking for.
This doesn't work when you run an A/B test on an email program. Especially when you are testing something like a subject line or time of day send where there is no separate email asset.