Some background... we have the following lead status: Suspect, Prospect, MQL, SAL, SQL, SQO.
The step was:
Remove From Flow-- If Lead Status -- Is Not-- Suspect, Prospect
Here's the screenshot
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/3efd6/3efd69f0a7e07df8bd46b43cfe08ab84b05ea86c" alt="0EM50000000RL33.jpg 0EM50000000RL33.jpg"
Since they were converted and moved to contacts, I would have thought this would have removed them.
Any help would be appreciated!