I think i understand what you are saying, so my subdomian redirect should be a CName and not an AName?
I think i understand what you are saying, so my subdomian redirect should be a CName and not an AName?
It must be CNAME record, absolutely.
Not an A record, and not an ANAME.
Sanford thank you for all the help. I made that change and it seems like it got Marketo to take the email one (em.getinsite.io) but it still is saying invalid CName subscription for the landing page one (go.getinsite.io). They both are pointing at the current spot and everything seems like it's correct, could it be that this one hasn't fully propagated yet? Seems weird to have one that is working and the one that isn't.
Neither of your aliases (em.getinsite.io and go.getinsite.io) are pointing to the right CNAME!
The aliases are both set up, but they both point to the CNAME getinsite.io (the zone apex). This will not work for either one.
You showed what looked to be the right CNAMEs in your screenshot above (mkto-*.com, *.mktoweb.com), don't know why you set them differently.