This is a common issue with any form fields you wish to reuse. We're running into a similar situation with our contact-us form - specifically with the open text field for a visitor to type in their question/request. Should they ever return to the site - and specifically to the contact us page - that field will pre-populate with their last question/request (unless you turn off auto-fill). Furthermore, even if we have auto-fill turned off, their submitted question/request will overwrite the earlier one.
Basically, any time you wish to retain historical data, you need to create a custom field for that specific form.