Hi Christina, I believe your company is using the SMB Standard Edition. If so, you won't be able to get everything you are looking for in the standard report types. You would need to upgrade to SMB Select Edition, which includes Revenue Cycle Explorer (RCE). That would provide all the metrics available in the Analyzer drop-downs.
For more on RCE, see: http://community.marketo.com/MarketoDeepDive?id=kA5500000008QOfCAM
Michael, I was told by support that it would not be possible and it does not exist in Marketo. I would want a single excel sheet for the data behind the "Program Analyzer" graph.