Hey Christina,
You need to be careful which fields you are looking at. There are two for created date:
- "Created": Date Lead was created in Mkto
- "SFDC Created Date": Date Lead was created in SFDC
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/e736a/e736a7814321502b93d95604f302d719e788a9fc" alt="0EM50000000RNmB.jpg 0EM50000000RNmB.jpg"
The data you are looking for should be available for you. Is this for reporting in Mkto?